Are you looking for the BEST electric smoker?
Don’t worry, the BBQ Diva has you covered! I’ve tested all of the most popular electric smokers on Amazon, and I have come up with this extensive buyer’s guide to help you make the right decision.
Why chose an electric smoker over a comparable gas, charcoal or wood smoker?
You can simply set it and forget it. You get all of the convenience of an oven, but with the added smokey flavor you’re looking for.
Best Electric Smokers 2017
Choosing the right smoker can be a big decision. They range in price from a little over $100 to well over $500. Keeping track of all of the features can be overwhelming, so I have made it easy for you.
|Bradley Smokers Original||Black||30 inch|
|Smokehouse Products Little Chief||Silver||30 inch|
|Masterbuilt Bluetooth||Silver w/window||30 inch|
|Char-Broil Vertical||Black||30 inch|
|Smoke Hollow||Silver w/window||30 inch|
BBQ Diva is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com
#1 Masterbuilt Digital – Best Overall Value
The Masterbuilt 30” Digital Electric Smoker is ranked as the most popular smoker on Amazon. It’s affordable price, consistency, worth and easy usage have made it user’s favorite electronic smoker
Whether you are a beginner or a pro, the Masterbuilt Digital Electric Smoker is perfect for you. The confusion of time and temperature adjustment and the hassle of charcoal or wood are not a problem when you have this ultimate Masterbuilt digital smoker in your house. All you need to do is plug in the machine, digital set the controls and get started. The Masterbuilt 30” Digital Electric Smoker has made smoking way too easy.
The digital temperature of the Masterbuilt digital smoker can range from anywhere up to 275 degrees Fahrenheit providing consistent smoking. The time and temperature are set with the digital control panel, the rest of the work is done by this efficient smoker itself. The simple smoker has a wide cooking space that can facilitate huge pieces of meat for a grand party. The interior space (about 750 square inches), that is a problem in most electric smokers is not a problem in the Masterbuilt smoker.
The famous smoker is ranked among the best electric smokers because of its ease of use. Apart from the simple digital controls and adjustments, the digital smoker comes with a small side door wood chip loading feature. Checking out the processed meat has become easier via this feature without having to open up the main cabinet of the smoker while smoking.
The Masterbuilt smoker has upgraded and improved a lot over the years. Apart from the digital panel control and side wood chip loading system, it now comes with four chrome-coated smoking racks. The smoker’s body is also fully insulated for quality performance in both hot and cold weather conditions.
Pros and Cons
Most of purchasers of the Masterbuilt Electric Smoker find it very easy and handy to use, however, a few problems exist. The Pros and Cons are discussed separately in detail below.
The quality of the Masterbuilt electric smoker makes it stand out among other smokers. The well-insulated body inside out and the perfectly aligned racks make smoking much easier.The digital panel control has made the use of this electric smoker even more simple. With a single touch of a button, the smoker starts its job. What else would a customer require?The temperature and the smoke remain consistent and accurate throughout the processing period. The results are thus, amazing.The machine now comes with wheels that make it portable. Also, the compact structure makes it easier to move it to another place. The cooking in the backyard sounds more fun with the Masterbuilt electric smoker in the house.
Many purchasers are annoyed that they have to refill the water pan so often, as this can be a chore. The digital smokers require some assembly. Customers have been facing difficulties in the assembly of certain parts of this machine, although I had no issues with it.
I have spent a lot of money on smokers due to their inconsistent heating. I have even burnt meat a couple of times because of temperature issues with other electric smokers. The Masterbuilt Digital Electric Smoker solved this problem for me, and this is part of the reason why I think this is the best electric smoker you can buy. Now I can easily adjust the temperature according to my need. The heat remains consistent and produces the best-smoked meat. I love how this electric smoker can be moved from one place to another. I had no issues transporting this smoker while we were moving to our new house. Its compact structure makes it even handier. One can easily use it to smoke food in the backyard on a windy day. I am so glad that I bought the Masterbuilt 30” Digital Electric Smoker.
The Masterbuilt Digital Electric Smoker earned the #1 spot on our list for a reason.
With an accurate temperature control and an automatic wood feeder system, the Bradley Smokers Original electric smoker has become popular among many regular and irregular cooks like me. The smoker promises quality and clean cooking within a short time span.
The Bradley Original Smoker is an easy to use electric smoker with an insulated stainless steel interior that’s easy to maintain and clean. The insulation is such that one can easily enjoy smoking food on hot or cold days while maintaining the required temperature. It has a unique automatic heat control system for keeping up the desired smoke consistency. The maximum temperature it allows is 250 degrees Fahrenheit. The electric smoker can go working for eight hours without refueling. It has two individual burners; one allows interior heating while the other is used for smoke generation. Also, it has four fully supported cooking racks that keep the food safe while loading and unloading. Additionally, the Bradley electric smoker now comes with a removable side panel for easy maintenance of the product. The cooker can be used as a roasting oven or a slow smoker according to one’s desire. Also, this electric smoker comes with a year’s warranty that ensures its quality features.
Pros and Cons
While searching for the Original Bradley Smoker over the internet, I came across many customer reviews that mostly gave some positive feedback. However, there are some cons which prevent me from giving this my top rating. The Pros and Cons are discussed separately in detail below.
The upgraded version of the product comes up with a stainless steel interior that cleans up without putting in any effort. The heat and smoke are very consistent in the Bradley original smoker. The automatic smoke control produces the best quality food. The temperature control is very easy to adjust. . Its well-insulated body makes it functional in any kind of weather condition. You can smoke your food for eight hours without refueling after which the automatic operation refuels it. What could be better?
The electronic heating elements and rods inside may give out over time. This usually happens when the smoke fumes block the fuel chamber. If you are thinking of feeding a large number of guests, the Bradley just doesn’t have the capacity for it.
My personal experience with the Bradley Original electronic smoker has been fantastic. It has been almost five years since I purchased this electronic smoker and it never gave me a hint of an issue, although I have seen some reports of reliability issues. I have smoked different types of meat including chicken, fish and beef and every time the smoker surprises me with the amount of smoke flavor it is able to impart. The best thing about this smoker is that I don’t need to spend hours cleaning it. The stainless steel interior and exteriors are totally flawless in this regard. Also, I can go months without using this electronic smoker and it always starts up as if it were brand new. Because of the reports of mechanic issues, I can’t say that this is the best electric smoker.
The Bradley Smokers Original Smoker comes in at #2 on my list because of reports of reliability issues.
If you are looking for the best electric smoker for smoking up to fifty pounds of meat, this little chief smoker will help you a lot. The smoker is designed for fish, beef, poultry, pork, and chicken of course. With a 250 watt element and 4-5 grills, the little chief produces some delicious smoked food.
This popular electric smoker accommodates and smokes as much as fifty pounds of meat without using any fire or charcoal. The heat is adjusted at 165 degrees Fahrenheit by a heating element that consumes 250 watts. The smoker is covered with aluminum on all four sides that make its body durable and long lasting. The best part about the little chief is the flavor fuel pan that smokes your food with your desired flavor. The fuel pan has a great capacity for facilitating bigger pieces of meat. The maintenance and clean up system is made easier by the dishwasher safe drip pan at the bottom of the smoker. Also, the fully chromed slide plates help to load and unload food properly. The newest Little Chief Front Load Smokers comes with a Smokehouse recipe book and some basic guidelines for how to get started. The smoker comes as a complete product and requires no assembly.
Pros and Cons
I bought this product after being convinced by the product’s beautiful description and was NOT disappointed. However, there were a few things that I personally believe could be improved about this smoker by the manufacturers. I have discussed the positives and the negatives of this product below.
The best thing about this product is that it comes as a fully assembled machine. Normally the smokers in the market have to be assembled before getting started. Sometimes the assembly becomes a difficult task. The Little Chief Front Load Smoker is best in this regard. The maximum capacity flavor fuel pans add to the beauty of this smoker. You can smoke your favorite flavored foods in the little chief. The Smokehouse recipe booklet that comes along is a great help. Despite being a good cook, this recipe booklet helped me a lot in improving my smoking food skills. The capacious machine allows smoking even up to fifty pounds of meat. The capacity problems that comes with most electric smokers is now solved by our favorite little chief smoker.Most of all, the little chief smoker is very simple to use. All you do is, add in your favorite flavor and place in the meat. The rest is done by the smoker itself.
The temperature is set to 165 degrees Fahrenheit, which is a huge disadvantage of this smoker. The temperature should be made adjustable for desired results.
I bought the Little Chief Front Load Smoker many years back used and it still works perfectly fine for me. I am really bad at technical things so when I first opened the box I was literally thrilled to see the already assembled machine inside. I love the Smokehouse recipe booklet that came along. Before buying this product, I did not know a thing about smoking fish. Today, I feel that the little chief works best for smoking fish. The capacity it provides makes it stand out among all other electric smokers. With this smokehouse product, I can cook my favorite flavored smoked food for three or four families at a family reunion.
The Little Chief Front Load Smoker takes #3, due it’s solid construction. The fixed temperature controller really holds it back, however.
The Masterbuilt Bluetooth Electric Smoker is one of the most diverse and convenient products that I came across, after searching for quite a while in the market. It is one of the best electric smokers with many unique inherent features. The Bluetooth feature, proper temperature control system, and in-built sensors are a few to mention here. The product has been highly rated by the users. This electric smoker has solved all the troubles associated with those traditional smokers. High grade technological and electronic components have been utilized in its manufacturing. This guide will further help you to understand various features, working principal and advantages of this smoker. If you are a techie like me, then this is the electronic smoker for you.
It is silver in color and made up of steel. The Masterbuilt Smoker has an inbuilt Bluetooth technology that will allow you to control the temperature from your mobile devices. You don’t have to stay attached to the smoker to control its temperature. It has a large 721 inches smoking space. Further, it has an internal temperature control system with built-in thermometer. There is a side wood loading chip system. An 800-watt heating element is there, which can smoke up to the 275 degrees temperature. The weight of this smoker is 54 pounds. The sturdily, and technical built-up with an attractive design is what makes it distinctive. These features together make it compelling enough to buy.
Pros and Cons
While I wanted to love this smoker for its technology, it falls a little short in the reliability department.
I would rate it 5 stars if the bluetooth were more relaible. It smoked the food items so perfectly and deliciously. The Bluetooth with an external device control system is the most appealing feature that is installed in this smoker, I just wish it worked all the time. The wide temperature control range allows you to smoke anything! Traditional low and slow BBQ can be done at 225 degrees, or milder smoking at 60 degrees for things like cheese or fish can be done. I love its temperature controlling mechanism, as it does a great job. The meat probe is one of the unique features as it allows the proper temperature for the meat cooking. Back wheels have made the work of moving the smoker, from one place to other, very easy.
The Masterbuilt Bluetooth Smart Digital Smoker takes #4, due it’s flaky bluetooth connection. The built-in temperature probe helps to boost its rank, however.
The Char-Broil Vertical Electric Smoker is an electronic smoker with many distinctive features that has enabled it to stand out on the list of best smokers. Some of those features include the consolidated framework, accurate temperature monitoring system and proper insulation. The Char-Broil comes it at the lowest price on our list and does not disappoint. The build quality is surprisingly good.
The Char-Broil Vertical Electric Smoker comes in an intense black color. The dimensions are 17.5 x 20 x 37.8 inches. It has a cooking surface of 505 square inches. There are three adjustable cooking grates. The Smoker has an insulated construction with double walls that allows an even temperature control for the cooking. The wood chips and water pan are also included. A chrome plated handle allows the ease of opening the Smoker and checking the stage of cooking. There is a grease cup assembly, one water pan, one wooden chip box and one wooden chip box lid. There are two side handles and three cooking grates. The temperature can reach up to three hundred degrees which mean you can smoke any food item from your list. The Smoker has the capability of cold smoking too as the temperature can be easily lowered and equally maintained as well.
Pros and Cons
The Char-Broil comes in as the cheapest electric smoker on our list, but its surprising build quality makes it a good buy. There are some fitment issues with the lid, however.
After the product arrived, it only took me 20 minutes to assemble it. The directions are easy to follow. Temperature balance is one of this smoker’s greatest strengths. The temperature dial can be rotated to adjust the temperature with precision.
The Char-Broil Vertical Electric Smoker takes #5, due it’s solid construction, but fitment issues hold it back.
There are many distinctive features of this smoker that enables the smoking of various products very quickly and efficiently. The internal temperature control is aptly regulated by the device to cook the food from all dimensions. Moreover, It has a LED display for controlling the temperature and for on/off mechanism. The transparent glass window is nice, but you can’t see the food when the smoke is rolling, and is more of a gimmick than a feature.
It is made up of stainless steel. The dimensions include 30 inches in size with 51 pounds weight and an ample 2 cubic feet cooking capacity. The temperature range of this Smoker is from 100F – 300F. The LED display has enabled an easy on/off and temperature set systems. The food gets perfectly smoked with the enhanced flavors. Many food items like meat, pork, wild game, poultry, cheese, and fish can be perfectly smoked to add the supplemental flavors. The temperature control is very efficient and can be adjusted according to the food item. You can also cook your vegetables to give a delicious Smokey taste to them. The 1500 watt heat source is connected that can allow you to suitably and deeply cook your meat items without leaving any chunk undercooked.
Pros and Cons
The directions are very easy to follow and the assembling gets easier as you go along. The LED digital controller has very good sensors and it makes the monitoring and temperature control quite efficient. I had a successful experience when I tried my first dish. The delicious taste of my smoked meat, which got amplified by this smoker, was appreciated by all my friends. The price factor is another commodious feature that adds to its qualities.
The Smoke Hollow Digital Smoker rounds out this list at #6, due to the fact that the window, while nice, is really nothing more than a gimmick.
Electric Smokers – Buyer’s Guide
While you may not get the pronounced smoke profile that an offset will give you, the convenience factor of being able to set the temperature and walk away is priceless. People have been winning BBQ competitions with electric smokers for years now. If the pros can do it, so can you!
Things to look for in an Electric Smoker
Now that you have decided that you want to purchase an electric smoker, what do you need to look for?
Don’t worry, I have all the answers!
- Variable temperature controller – Controlling the temperature correctly is the key to making great BBQ. Without a variable temperature controller, you’re stuck with whatever temperature the manufacturer decided would be best. Do yourself a favor a skip any electric smoker without a variable temperature controller!
- Form fitting lid – If the lid doesn’t fit very well, then lot of smoker and heat will be siphoned out of the cooking chamber, leading to inconsistent temperatures, inefficient cooking, and a lot of wasted energy! If the lid doesn’t fit, send it back!
- Easy way to add wood chips – This is important. Unless you buy a model with an automatic feeding apparatus, like the Bradley model listed above, you will be feeding wood chips every 30-45 minutes. Make sure the system your electric smoker uses has an easy way to add wood chips!
Phew! I am tired from typing all of that information.
Are you sure you got it all? If not, there are navigation links on the sidebar that will help you quickly find what you are looking for. I have shown you a review of 6 electric smokers that I think will meet your needs, with a buying guide to help you make the right choice.
The true overall winner, when it comes to price, features, and just rugged durability, is the Masterbuilt Digital Electric Smoker. It is a great value and will produce great BBQ for years to come.
As always, if you have any questions, you can leave a comment or question below, and I will reply right away.